Talk:Korematsu v. United States

Related articles

While I've been focused on more recent aspects and haven't given extensive coverage to the Japanese internment, let me mention a set of evolving new articles that I've posted; I cite this article at the middle level:

• Extrajudicial detention
  • Extrajudicial detention, U.S.
    • Extrajudicial detention, U.S., George W. Bush Administration

There's a parallel hierarchy of:

• Interrogation
  • Intelligence interrogation, U.S.
    • Intelligence interrogation, U.S., George W. Bush Administration

These replace earlier articles that were U.S.-centric at the top of the hierarchy. You'll also find a number of supporting articles, not so much for this one but universal jurisdiction, international extradition, and extraordinary rendition. I know we need to get something on Posse Comitatus Act. Howard C. Berkowitz 16:21, 13 March 2009 (UTC)

I did nominate the article for CZ:Article of the Week.Howard C. Berkowitz 22:40, 19 March 2009 (UTC)

Parent article

The lead infers Japanese interment, but that's a little vague. What would encompass both the internment and legal issues? Some thoughts:

• Extrajudicial detention, U.S., WWII Japanese internment
• Second World War, U.S., interment of persons of Japanese interment

I'm trying to be factual, not editorializing in the title; I'll also be doing an article on the 442nd Regimental Combat Team. There may indeed be links, at the higher hierarchical, to the dynamics of U.S.-Japanese relations, not just combat, but diplomatic issues (e.g., the embargo after expansion into French Indonesia and even vignettes such as Guy Gabaldon. Howard C. Berkowitz 22:40, 19 March 2009 (UTC)

I'm still kind of fuzzy on the guidelines for creating hierarchies of articles. Is there supposed to be just one "parent"? It seems to me both of your suggestions make sense, as might something about SCOTUS cases, or more narrowly, SCOTUS cases dealing with civil rights/liberties. Shamira Gelbman 22:09, 20 March 2009 (UTC)

Nawww, we aren't too biological; we accept any number of parents. For that matter, it's no sin to have parent articles that are illustrative, where one is actually the parent of another.

I hadn't thought of a SCOTUS civil liberties article, but that's a good idea. I don't think we have all our SCOTUS articles pointing there; perhaps there should be a SCOTUS catalog subpage listing cases, possibly by type. Catalogs are useful for things too large or complex for the Related Article structure. Howard C. Berkowitz 22:16, 20 March 2009 (UTC)

From the "aftermath" section

This bit of text from the article's last section would probably be more suited to an article about the Japanese internment more generally rather than the Korematsu case in particular. I'm moving it here until that page is developed:

The Congress passed the Japanese American Evacuation Claims Act to provide compensation to Japanese properties damaged during the "relocation". In 1980 the Congress opened an investigation to the internment program and a report titled "Personal Justice Denied" was written. The report condemned the "relocation" and the Korematsu court decision. In 2001, the PBS broadcast a Eric Paul Fournier film Of Civil Wrongs and Rights in memory of the Japanese internment and the Korematsu litigation.