Archive:Proposals/Policy

How to make a proposal

Part of making a clear proposal is stating what your proposal is, as well as providing statements that support your argument. Making a proposal without any reasoning will probably not be viewed very well, or convincingly (or worst case, ignored!). The justifications for your proposal should be written neatly, and succinctly. If the proposal being made has had prior discussion, it might be appropriate to include links to those discussions, and maybe a summary of the different views on the topic.

Example:

Proposal: The Citizendium Logo should be colored red.

Justification(s):

1. Red is a good, bright indicator color
2. Red draws attention
3. Red is known for it's "bold" appeal
4. Red is used to indicate something important

--Robert W King 07:47, 9 February 2008 (CST)

Always remember to include your name when making a proposal. You can do this by simply clicking the "Your signature with timestamp" button on the edit toolbar or by adding --~~~~ to the last line of your proposal.

The easiest way to make a proposal is to use the {{proposal}} template, located at Template:Proposal. This is a pre-formatted template that creates a subheader, and has variable fields that can be filled in to quickly establish your proposal.

The proposal template

Summary: Please edit your proposal record and provide a summary. Original proposer: Please specify original proposer (i.e., person who added the proposal to this page) Next step: Fill in next step Driver: Driver needed (i.e., someone familiar with the proposals system who will move it through the system) To be done by: Fill in target date for next step

To the proposer: please read the proposals system policy page if you want to fill out a complete proposal, not just this summary. If you don't, please ask around for someone (a "driver") to take over your proposal! Start complete proposal

The response template

Response

By: --Robert W King 09:31, 9 February 2008 (CST)

It should be blue because it matches the rest of the wiki theme colors.

How not to make a proposal

Bad proposals are not supported by any statements, and are not formatted well. Also notice that no name has been provided. Although you would be able to tell who made the proposal through the page history, it makes it inconvenient to your audience.

Example:

Proposal; the citiz should use green. I like green as a color, it looks better.

Also, CZ:Proposals is not the place to start arguments, or stage a coup. You may not make any proposals that a citizen should be removed from the project, or a proposal that "so-and-so is a jerk." Any ill-intent caused will be taken very seriously, and will be removed from this page by the constabulary with swift impudence.

After a proposal has been made

When presenting an idea, it is appropriate to get the appropriate community input on the proposition. If you are making a suggestion about the way mathematics formulae should be formatted, obviously you would not want to bring it to the attention of the 'History Workgroup'. The most concerned parties would be the Mathematics and Sciences workgroups.

Remember that the Citizendium is largely a volunteer-based project, and it may take some time in order to receive responses to your proposal. In some cases, making a small recommendation may have sweeping consequences, and those should be considered.

Queue

See CZ:Proposals/Queue for a queue of proposals if this page becomes policy.