CZ:Editorial Council Resolution 0011: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>David E. Volk
(→‎Discussion: signing my stuff)
imported>Martin Baldwin-Edwards
No edit summary
Line 22: Line 22:
== Discussion ==
== Discussion ==
*Proposal outline: [[CZ:Proposals/Create_workgroup_style_guides]]
*Proposal outline: [[CZ:Proposals/Create_workgroup_style_guides]]
*[http://mail.citizendium.org/pipermail/cz-editcouncil/2008-June/000467.html Initial (private) comments]
*[http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php/topic,1763.0.html Forum discussion on Resolution 0011]
*[http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/CZ:Editorial_Council_Resolution_0011/Member_position_statements Member position statements]


I would like to address a few concerns raised by the private comments:


1) '''lead editor''' is not any kind of power position.  By this term I meant lead editor for the first draft on the style guide, nothing more.  He would not have power to overrule others, but is rather the first volunteer for his workgroup.  The Chemistry style guide was basically written like this:
:a) I wrote a first rough draft
:b) I sent email to active chemistry group participants and asked for more input
:c) We edited the guide
:d) Other have continued to add material as they see fit, without my involvement or consent.
2) The style guide is mostly for reminding people of things not to forget and pointing out where to find things.
Style of prose is not something that will generally be included in the style guides.  This material is covered
by CZ-wide policy already and often ignored anyway.
3) The style guide's main purpose is to be helpful to authors and editors, not to ruin their writing experience
or drive them away.
4) The style guide will be a living, growing thing, edited by both authors and editors of the workgroup
: At one point not so long ago, CZ did not use subpages, now it does.
When I first got here, we did not have chem_infobox or elem_infobox, now we do.  A style guide for authors helps
to point out these new things as they arrive. [[User:David E. Volk|David E. Volk]] 09:13, 17 June 2008 (CDT)


== Sponsors ==
== Sponsors ==

Revision as of 09:42, 17 June 2008

The resolution

Whereas, CZ wishes to promote a professional image, which requires some consistency of style and format of articles;

Whereas, different disciplines may require different approaches, thus ruling out a common standard for all articles, even within the same workgroup;

Whereas, general guidance for authors remains limited, and is easier to develop within workgroups;

Resolved, That Citizendium will develop a range of workgroup stylesheets for the guidance of authors and editors

Method of execution

The Council will call for a lead editor in each workgroup, to oversee and develop the stylesheet or stylesheets for that workgroup

Amendments

Vote

Current status

Discussion


Sponsors

Before it is added to the Agenda, these sponsors, but only these sponsors, may edit the text of the resolution. After it is added to the Agenda, it cannot be edited by anyone except via the amendment process.

Resolution history

  • Proposed: 09 June, 2008
  • Entered queue: (bypassed queue)
  • Entered initial discussion: 10 June, 2008 for 6 days
  • Entered public discussion: 17 June, 2008 for 7 days
  • Entered discussion of Amendment 1:
  • Scheduled close of discussion of Amendment 1:
  • Entered voting on motion to amend
  • Close of voting motion to amend
  • Entered voting on resolution:
  • Close of voting on resolution:


The Editorial Council was merged with the Management Council into a single governing body in 2013. All EC rules and decisions were upheld
except where they contradicted the merger. The following links are to archived and out-of-date pages:
 Mailing List Archives • Resolutions • Log • Essential Policy • Rules of Procedure • How to Make a Resolution
Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=CZ:Editorial_Council_Resolution_0011&oldid=490107"